
Country Garden Triumphs in Landmark Forest City Purchaser Suits
10.11.2025Forest City has long carried the "ghost city" label. In our November 2025 article, we reported on four purchasers who tried to set aside their sale and purchase agreements (SPAs). We also mentioned a case still to come. A Shanghai businessman had agreed to buy ten Forest City apartments for approximately RM6.1 million before he had ever visited the development. What persuaded him to buy all ten? Read our earlier article.
On 18 November 2026, the Johor Bahru High Court dismissed Lu Jun’s claim for a refund of approximately RM2.79 million. The Court allowed the developer’s counterclaim in part and ordered specific performance of all ten SPAs. Lu Jun must pay the outstanding purchase price, and the developer must deliver vacant possession in accordance with the agreements.
Why ten apartments?
Lu Jun said a sales agent in Shanghai had promised him one free place in the Malaysia My Second Home (MM2H) programme for each apartment. On his account, ten units meant ten places.
The High Court accepted that CGPV was answerable for what its agent said. The difficulty for Lu Jun was proving the promise itself. Each form he signed offered help with one MM2H application per property. Approval rested with the authorities, and Lu Jun never applied. The allegation that each unit came with a guaranteed place emerged only in re-examination. Neither his pleadings nor his witness statement had put his case that way.
The timing of the sales presentation mattered too. Lu Jun relied on statements about a railway and other smart-city features. On his own account, he saw that presentation during his first visit to Johor. By then, he had already signed all ten SPAs and paid the deposit. The presentation could not have induced him to buy.
Even if he had proved misrepresentation, was he in time?
The judge addressed limitation as an alternative ground. Even if Lu Jun had proved misrepresentation, she would have held that the six-year period ran from the dates he signed the SPAs in 2016. His last instalment payment in November 2017 did not restart time. By the time he filed suit in March 2023, the six years had expired.
Earlier Forest City decisions
Lu Jun follows several purchaser disputes in which IKC successfully represented CGPV:
(a) In Wong Yong Fook & Anor v Country Garden Pacificview Sdn Bhd, the Court of Appeal unanimously dismissed the purchasers’ appeals and upheld the findings that the SPAs were valid and enforceable.
(b) In separate claims against Lim Hwa Ping, Nyuin Anak Angat and Liew Kok Chong, CGPV obtained summary judgment for specific performance. The court also dismissed the purchasers’ counterclaims.
(c) In the four purchaser suits tried together that we reported on in November 2025, the court dismissed the claims to set aside the SPAs and allowed CGPV’s counterclaims for specific performance.
(d) In the Limkokwing University of Creative Technology International Sdn Bhd matter, the High Court ordered specific performance and payment of approximately RM1.72 million in outstanding purchase price. The purchaser has appealed that decision.
A Precedent for the Industry
The most telling finding in Lu Jun is that the purchaser succeeded on the question of agency and still lost his claim. The developer had to answer for what its sales agent said in Shanghai. The purchaser, in turn, had to prove what the agent promised and how it induced him to sign. Later headlines might explain why a buyer came to regret a purchase. They could tell the Court little about the conversation that led him to buy.
For developers and purchasers alike, the practical consequence is significant. The Court looked at the forms Lu Jun signed, the sequence of events and his own account of the sale. On that evidence, it held both parties to their bargain and ordered all ten purchases to proceed.
Sze Jia, Aleeya, Qi Si and Poh Yee represeted the developer. Sze Jia can be reached at szejia@ikclaw.com, Aleeya at aleeya@ikclaw.com, and Qi Si at qisi@ikclaw.com






